Romancing History

Did Cooks Use Spices to Mask Rotting Meat?

As a lover of history and historical tidbits, I’m always surprised when I discover that something I’d learned as “fact,” simply isn’t true. Sometimes these erroneous facts spread because they are humorous or shocking and easily stick in our memories, but more often than not, they contain just enough truth to make them believable–like today’s topic, whether or not cooks used spices to mask the smell and/or taste of rotting meat.

This statement usually rears its head in reference to either Medieval or Colonial times. Either way, it just isn’t true.

Locked Spice Cabinet, circa 1170-1789, courtesy Colonial Williamsburg Foundation

Imported from the Spice Islands like Indonesia, Sri Lanka, and Malaysia, spices that we consider common today like pepper, cinnamon, and cloves, were once hugely expensive. So expensive, that rare spices were often kept under lock and key. A pound of saffron sold for the same price as a horse. A pound of nutmeg? That would cost the same as seven oxen.

Therefore, adding exotic spices to your meat was a status symbol, and it meant you had money to spare on extravagant items. Likewise, you were not the type of person who ate spoiled meat.

So how did this idea seep into the historical vernacular? Food historian Daniel Myers says the myth can most likely be traced to a man named Jack Cecil Drummond. In his book, The Englishman’s Food, Drummond misinterprets a pivotal word  that he uses to justify his theory. Myers points out the word “greene” is used in medieval writings not to describe the color of meat, as Drummond erroneously concluded, but that the meat is unready in reference to the practice of letting meat age before cooking. In addition, Drummond himself actually cites numerous reasons why his tainted meat theory just doesn’t make sense—including documenting laws and punishments for butchers and grocers that served unsafe food.

Join the Conversation: What’s a go to spice in your cupboard?


McCormick Science Institute: History of Spices
Drummond’s Rotten Meat: When Good Sources Go Bad, Daniel Myers



The Forgotten History Behind Patriot’s Courage & a Giveaway by Penelope Marzec


A Bridge to the Past


  1. Thanks for correcting our mistaken history! With the spice cabinet I have, I must be able to afford a whole herd of animals!

  2. Carol James

    Well, well. I was taught they did use spices to cover up the taste of bad meat. But having lived in a culture where the meat hung outside and was covered with “green” I can understand how Drummond might have drawn that conclusion. Glad to have that myth debunked!! Thanks, Kelly.

    • romancinghistory

      Hi Carol, I was taught the same thing. It makes sense but this research seemed to make even more to me. This is launching a new series for me on historical myths debunked based on a book I picked up. Hope you stick around to see more in the coming weeks.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén